The Debate that Made Bart Ehrman a Legend: “Are the Gospels Historically Reliable?”

October 28, 2026

New Testament scholar Bart Ehrman argued that the Gospels are not historically reliable because they contain contradictions and were written decades after Jesus’ death by non-eyewitnesses.

In these debates, Ehrman contends that the Gospels are theological proclamations rather than objective biographies, citing discrepancies in details such as the genealogies, the timing of Jesus’ death, and the accounts of the empty tomb as evidence that they cannot be trusted as accurate historical records.

Opponents in these debates, such as Jimmy Akin, Mike Licona, Craig Evans, and Peter J. Williams, argue that Ehrman applies an anachronistic standard of “just the facts” reporting to ancient texts, asserting that the Gospels exhibit verisimilitude and contain reliable historical information despite minor variations.

Key debates featuring this topic include:

Ehrman vs. Mike Licona (2018): A public debate at Kennesaw State University where Ehrman criticized Licona’s lenient criteria for historical reliability.
Ehrman vs. Craig Evans (2010): A debate resulting in the book Can We Trust the Bible on the Historical Jesus?, focusing on whether the Gospels preserve Jesus’ teachings and activities accurately.
Ehrman vs. Jimmy Akin (2022): A debate hosted by Catholic Answers regarding the trustworthiness of the Gospels as true accounts of Jesus’ life and teaching.
Ehrman vs. Peter J. Williams (2018/2022): A discussion on the “Unbelievable?” show, where Ehrman acknowledged some historical information in the Gospels but maintained they are not generally historically trustworthy.

What Does The KJV Bible Say?

Bart Ehrman’s historical-critical method views the Gospels as human, historically conditioned texts containing factual contradictions, variants, and theological developments rather than infallible records. In debates concerning the historical reliability of the Gospels (specifically framed around the King James Version), Ehrman argues that scribal alterations, missing original manuscripts, and internal discrepancies undermine absolute historical precision.

To break down this famous debate premise, the internal KJV discrepancies, and how different intellectual and theological figures analyze Ehrman’s perspective, this report is divided into a comparative textual matrix followed by individual analytical profiles.

Part 1: 10 Examples of Gospel Discrepancies (KJV)

This table contrasts historical or narrative tensions within the King James Version (KJV) Gospels that form the core of historical-critical debates.

#	Event / Topic	Gospel Account A (KJV)	Gospel Account B (KJV)	The Historical-Critical Dilemma
1	The Genealogy of Jesus	Matthew 1:16: Jacob begat Joseph, the husband of Mary. (26 generations from David).	Luke 3:23-31: Joseph, which was the son of Heli. (41 generations from David).	Divergent bloodlines and names for Joseph’s father.
2	Timing of the Crucifixion	Mark 15:25: “And it was the third hour, and they crucified him.”	John 19:14: Jesus was still on trial before Pilate at “about the sixth hour.”	A chronological mismatch of several hours regarding the execution.
3	The Death of Judas	Matthew 27:5: He “cast down the pieces of silver… and went and hanged himself.”	Acts 1:18: “Falling headlong, he burst asunder in the midst, and all his bowels gushed out.”	Contradictory accounts of the method and location of Judas’s death.
4	Jairus’s Daughter	Matthew 9:18: The ruler says, “My daughter is even now dead.”	Mark 5:23: The ruler says, “My little daughter lieth at the point of death.”	Disagreement on whether the girl was already dead or merely dying when requested.
5	The Centurion’s Request	Matthew 8:5: The centurion came in person, “beseeching him.”	Luke 7:3-6: The centurion never comes; he sends “elders of the Jews” and friends.	Discrepancy between a direct personal encounter vs. proxy messengers.
6	The Cleansing of the Temple	Mark 11:12-15: Occurs at the very end of Jesus’s ministry, right before the crucifixion.	John 2:13-16: Occurs at the absolute beginning of Jesus’s public ministry.	A major structural disruption in the timeline of Jesus’s public actions.
7	The Adulterous Woman Text	John 7:53–8:11: Retained in KJV (“He that is without sin…”).	Textual Criticism: Missing from the oldest, most reliable Greek manuscripts.	Ehrman highlights this as a later scribal insertion, not original history.
8	The Johannine Comma	1 John 5:7: “For there are three that bear record in heaven… and these three are one.”	Textual Criticism: Absent from ancient Greek MSS; added centuries later.	Used by Ehrman to prove theological tampering to reinforce the Trinity.
9	The Long Ending of Mark	Mark 16:9-20: Details post-resurrection appearances and snake handling.	Textual Criticism: Mark originally ended abruptly at verse 16:8 at the empty tomb.	Scribes added historical narrative to smooth over an abrupt ending.
10	Staff or No Staff?	Mark 6:8: Commands them to take nothing “save a staff only.”	Matthew 10:9-10 / Luke 9:3: Commands them to provide “neither staves.”	Direct contradiction regarding missionary equipment guidelines.

Part 2: Analyst Reports on Ehrman’s Claims

Myers-Briggs (MBTI) Analyst Report

Target Profile: INTJ / INTP (The Mastermind / The Logician)
Core Assessment: Ehrman operates out of a highly systematized Introverted Thinking (Ti) or Introverted Intuition (Ni) framework coupled with Extraverted Thinking (Te) logic. He breaks down large, sacred structures into individual data points (variants, manuscripts, historical context).
Conclusion: To an MBTI analyst, Ehrman’s debate style is persuasive because it removes emotional or spiritual bias (Feeling – F) in favor of rigorous, cold empirical consistency (Thinking – T). He wins by forcing the opponent out of abstract faith concepts into concrete textual data.

John MacArthur Analyst Report

Perspective: Reformed Evangelical Cessationist / Strict Biblical Inerrantist
Core Assessment: MacArthur rejects Ehrman’s fundamental premises entirely. From MacArthur’s worldview, the Bible is the inspired, inerrant Word of God. Variations in the KJV or Greek manuscripts do not point to historical unreliability, but rather to God’s sovereign preservation of His core truths through human copyists.
Conclusion: MacArthur views Ehrman not as a neutral historian, but as a spiritual skeptic blinding others. MacArthur argues that apparent discrepancies (like the genealogies or the centurion) are easily harmonized when recognizing the unique theological audiences of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.

Paul Washer Analyst Report

Perspective: Heart-cry Missionary / Radical Reformed Preacher
Core Assessment: Washer shifts the argument away from dry textual criticism to spiritual regeneration. Washer would argue that Ehrman’s obsession with historical minutiae is proof of an unregenerate heart that relies on human reason rather than the conviction of the Holy Spirit.
Conclusion: Washer posits that the reliability of the Gospels isn’t proven in an academic debate chamber by comparing KJV verses, but by the supernatural, transforming power of the Gospel message in the life of a repentant sinner. Scribes may make minor errors, but the living Word remains unshakeable.

Greg Schad Analyst Report

Perspective: Academic Apologist / Classical Debater
Core Assessment: Schad isolates the logical vulnerabilities in Ehrman’s methodology. He asserts that Ehrman sets an impossibly high standard for “historical reliability”—one that no ancient secular document (like Homer or Caesar) could ever pass.
Conclusion: Schad points out that minor variants in the KJV do not alter a single core Christian doctrine. By focusing heavily on micro-level scribal variations, Ehrman creates a rhetorical illusion of historical chaos, ignoring the fact that the macro-narrative of Jesus’s life, death, and resurrection remains incredibly stable across thousands of manuscripts.

Jordan Peterson Analyst Report

Perspective: Pragmatic Evolutionary Psychologist / Literary Mythologist
Core Assessment: Peterson views Ehrman’s historical hyper-literalism as missing the forest for the trees. Peterson argues that the Gospels are “more than true” because they capture the fundamental, archetypal underpinnings of human consciousness and Western morality.
Conclusion: Peterson contends that arguing whether a centurion walked or sent a friend, or whether a staff was carried, is a shallow, post-Enlightenment error. The historical reliability of the text is found in its profound psychological and narrative truth, which has successfully oriented human behavior toward the “Highest Good” for millennia.

Carl Jung Analyst Report

Perspective: Analytical Psychoanalyst
Core Assessment: Jung interprets the Gospels through the lens of the Collective Unconscious and archetypes. To Jung, the textual variations Ehrman exposes are completely natural expressions of the human psyche projecting the Christ Archetype (the Self) in slightly different cultural or individual variations.
Conclusion: Jung would analyze Ehrman’s debate as a conflict between the hyper-rational Ego (Ehrman) trying to dissect the numinous, transcendent Mythos (The Gospels). The historical discrepancies do not make the Gospels unreliable; rather, they prove that the Gospels are living psychic realities that morph as they pass through different human minds.

As You seek understanding and clarity in your life you should always turn to your Heavenly Father for Guidance

Table of Contents

Youtube Video (Todays Message)
Are You Your Own Worst Enemy?
Women are looking for a fathers love
Spiritual Order – In The Family and Church
How God Commands Us To Forgive Those Who We Have Resentment Toward
Join Our Newsletter
Top Seven Articles
Our Mission Statement
Our Vision
Tithing And Giving!

When Tithing please give what you feel is good to the amount we are helping you in your spiritual life.

Here is a YouTube video to help theses who need to understand someone explaining the important message, the YouTube video is called, “The Debate that Made Bart Ehrman a Legend: “Are the Gospels Historically Reliable?””, This video is with Trumpet of Glory YouTube Channel:

Note: MadeManMinistries.com has no relations with Trumpet of Glory YouTube Channel, but MadeManMinistries.com enjoys sharing the word.

Note: We do use YouTube Video’s under the “Fair Use” Act under the Copyright Law:

“Fair use is a doctrine in the United States copyright law codified in Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976.¹ It provides for the legal, non-licensed citation or incorporation of copyrighted material in another author’s work without requiring permission from the rights holders, such as for commentary, criticism, news reporting, research, teaching or scholarship.⁰¹ The U.S. Copyright Office Fair Use Index should prove helpful in understanding what courts have to date considered to be fair or not fair but it is not a substitute for legal advice.²“

Father God, Let Your Will Be Done, Not My Will mademanministries

This is a major important point about forgiveness

Leave there thy gift before the altar, and go thy way; first be reconciled to thy brother, and then come and offer thy gift. -MATTHEW 5:24 KJV

Are You Your Own Worst Enemy?

I would start out by saying what Jesus Christ would want us to do? Pray and how should we pray? The Lord’s Prayer, and how often should we pray? Continually. Why do we use the Lord’s Prayer and not some other? The Lord’s Prayer covers all the areas that is important for our spiritual being.

When we pray the Lords prayer we ask to forgive our enemies, let God’s will be done, the kingdom to come. By praying the Lord’s prayer we let go of many thoughts we have in our head and give them back to God so we can have things revealed to us.

We must overcome resentment in our heart, and in a past video I shared about Dr. Jordan Peterson talks about how resentment can destroy us and we become our own very worst enemy and Jordan goes on to say that we must talk to people what we have resentment toward to overcome that resentment. Other people who lived in the past who talked about this is Jesus Christ and someone who is living now who talks about this daily is Brother Augustine, Dr. John MacArthur, Dr. Charles Stanley, Rev. John Piper and Pastor Paul Washer.

Women are looking for a fathers love

Women are looking for a fathers love. Its important that men understand women are looking for a fathers love and not get screwed. Woman more than anything are looking for a strong spiritual man to lead the future (the family). I think in many YouTube videos on biblical teachings, how young women are being hurt by men that are just looking to get laid instead of doing right and being in Christ and setting a good example of a strong man. We must be in Christ, hate no one, love all, forgave theses we resent, love what is right and support people who are walking with God.

Women need their fathers in their lives to be strong man to be good examples and not BETA men or weak examples of what a man should be. Its important that a man leads the way as Christ leads men, we as man need to fellow Jesus Christ to keep society from going to HELL.

Every day you can see or people watch how some men and women our living in hell without the right spiritual order then you will continue your hellish way according to 2 Peter. You can also find it in Romans. God will give you over to a reprobate mind.

And even as they did not like to retain God in their knowledge, God gave them over to a reprobate mind, to do those things which are not convenient. – Romans 1:28 (KJV)

In Romans 1, Paul refers to something known as a reprobate mind. If you’re not familiar with the term reprobate, the literal definition in the Greek is failing to pass the test, unapproved, counterfeit.

Spiritual Order – In The Family and Church

God the father

Jesus Christ

Father (Men over women)

Mother (Women over children)

Here is Book, Chapter and Verse from the Kings James Version 1 Corinthian 11:2-16, But the main message is in 1 Corinthian 11:3: “³But I would have you know, that the head of every man is Christ; and the head of the woman is the man; and the head of Christ is God.”

A Woman Conferring The Spiritual Order According to Saint Paul And How The War On The Family Is Being Wage:

How You Treat People Is Who You Are! On Judgement Day You Will Be Judged How You Treated The Less Fortunate (Open Letter)

New Social Contract To Save The West!

Should America And The Western World Have A New Social Contract? (Open Letter)

Father’s Rights

Open Letter To: President Joe Biden, President Putin, Pope Francis, Governors Of All States In America (Any Government Leaders, Officials Who Call Jesus Christ Lord):

GARBAGE GENERATION

GARBAGE GENERATION By Daniel Amneus

$15.95 Price Check Ebay.com

Daniel Amneus – The Garbage Generation.pdf Link

Back to Patriarchy!

Back to Patriarchy! by Daniel Amneus

$29.95 Price Check Ebay.com

The Ten Lepers – Resource for Kids Ministry mademanministries — The Ten Lepers

Check out our newest website CIPADS.com place ads for business, jobs, real estate or another site like craigslist

How God Commands Us To Forgive Those Who We Have Resentment Toward.

All of us are tested everyday by our personal internal struggle coming from resentment of what happened earlier in our lives as children typically what our mother did to us, telling how our fathers were not good enough or driving us away from our fathers when we were children. We most go to the people that we have resentment against and forgive them. By forgiving our mothers or whoever we have resentment against, God will forgive us and we can return to the heavenly Father through our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.

It was said if you don’t love everyone then you love no one. People today live like the Old Testament people did. We must forgive and love everyone as God Commanded us to do according to Matthew 22:34-40.

After Reading The Passage I would Recommend Doing A Silent Prayer

Its is said: Be still, and know that I am God: I will be exalted among the heathen, I will be exalted in the earth. Psalm 46:10 King James Version (KJV)

Because He Lives - YouTube mademanministries

Jesus is an example of a Fathers loves

Join Our Newsletter

The List Children Of The Lie!!

People of the Lie : The Hope for Healing Human Evil

Average Rating: (3.6) stars out of 5 stars

$17.93 Buy now price check at Walmart

Special Articles:

Who Was Jezabelle In The Bible?

Is Malachi An Indictment Against Mankind?

What does the Bible say about breaking generational curses?

Its Time To Repeal Women’s Rights To Contact Your Elected Official

Is It Time To Establish Israel/The New Jerusalem As Head Of The World

The Terrifying Truth About The Antichrist

Sexual Revolution, Perverted Revolution, Then Reprobates

Are The Black Hebrew Israelites The Synagogue of Satan Accusation in Revelation 2:9?

A Wife Should Be “A Mirror” To Her Husband?

Father God I have to Say Society (Law Of Man) Has Given Me Reason To Blame The Woman You Given Me As Adam Did Eve In Genesis 3:12, But I Have To Take Responsibility As The Buck Stops With Me As I Am The Man In The Relationship, I Am The Head (Weak But The Head Of The Family)

Ethoipian Bible Was Never Translated In To English

The Anti-Christ Comes From The Sea, 12th Imam Comes From A Well, Are They The Same Person?

The Third Temple Prophecy 2026 and Red Heifers Ashes Update | End Times Bible Update

10 Biblical Drinks God Designed To Heal You Instantly

Every Letter the Apostle Paul Wrote, Explained in Chronological Order

Professor Jiang’s Real Identity – You Won’t Believe This, CCP Asset, Fake Analyst?

The Hidden Hebrew Meaning of “Image of God” (Not What You Think)

Heretic Series/Beware Of The Wolf In Sheeps Clothing

Is The Mormon Church Heretics? Of Arianism Heresy

Is Rev. Robert W. Lee A Heretic?

Does Gino Jennings Know Hes a Heretic? Of The Arianism Heresy Part Two

Is Islam And All Muslims Heretics? Of Arianism Heresy

Is Gino Jennings A Heretic? Of Arianism Heresy

Is Jesse Lee Peterson A Heretic? Of Arianism Heresy

Who Are the 5 percenter or 5%? Are They Heretics

Who Is Billy Carson? Why Does Billy Teach A Different Gospel Of Our Lord Jesus Christ?

In a world where it is so easy to forget the importance of God, we must remember that He is holy and will not share His glory. America has forgotten this truth and it is time for us to re-examine our relationship with God and recognize that He is the one true God who deserves our full devotion and reverence. We must remember that He will not be taken lightly or ignored, but rather should be honored as the Creator of all things. Only then can we truly experience His love and grace in our lives.

America Has Forgotten! That God The Father Is Holy And He Will Not Share His Glory!

God Reveals Himself

Click the link about a PDF how God reveals himself to you: God Reveals and Satan Speaks to you!

Our Mission Statement

Uniting men of good character who, though of different ethnic or social backgrounds, share a belief in the fatherhood of God and the brotherhood of mankind. Bring Men back to the Father and sharing the biblical view of the Heavenly Father.

Our Vision

By returning to our heavenly father God thru the Lord and Savior Jesus Christ we can rebuilt the family, once the man is recognized as the head of the family and household. Partner with us as we develop a community, mission, and leadership support for the men of today.

Now is the time for a new movement of men. As brothers, fathers let’s become who we’re created to be, knowing our identity, purpose, and destiny in Christ. Then let’s do, linking arms to change the world for good … and for God. Help bring transformation and revival to our families, churches, and communities.

Tithing And Giving!

When Tithing please give what you feel is good to the amount we are helping you in your spiritual life. We are a for profit Ministry meaning we take all profits or donations and give it back to the community we service. Please visit our sponsors down below or along the side of the website, Thanks.